Does Google systematically wipe out duplicated content? If so, does it affect partial dupes too? Will Google apply site-wide ’scraper penalties’ when a particular dupe-threshold gets reached or exceeded?
Following many ‘vanished page posts’ with links on message boards and usenet groups, and monitoring sites I control, I’ve found that indeed there is kinda pattern. It seems that Google is actively wiping dupes out. Those get deleted or stay indexed as ‘URL only’, not moved to the supplemental index.
Example: I have a script listing all sorts of widgets pulled from a database, where users can choose how many items they want to see per page (values for #of widgets/page are hard coded and all linked), combined with prev¦next-page links. This kind of dynamic navigation produces tons of partial dupes (content overlaps with other versions of the same page). Google has indexed way too many permutations of that poorly coded page, and foolishly I didn’t take care of it. Recently I got alerted as Googlebot-Mozilla requested hundreds of versions of this page within a few hours. I’ve quickly changed the script, putting a robots NOINDEX meta tag when the content overlaps, but probably too late. Many of the formerly indexed (cached, appearing with title and snippets on the SERPs) URLs have vanished, respectively became URL-only listings. I expect that I’ll lose a lot of ‘unique’ listings too, because I’ve changed the script in the middle of the crawl.
I’m posting this before I’ve solid data to backup a finding, because it is a pretty common scenario. This kind of navigation is used at online shops, article sites, forums, SERPs … and it applies to aggregated syndicated content too.
I’ve asked Google whether they have a particular recommendation, but no answer yet. Here is my ‘fix’:
Define a straight path thru the dynamic content, where not a single displayed entry overlaps with another page. For example if your default value for items per page is 10, the straight path would be:
Then check the query string before you output the page. If it is part of the straight path, put a INDEX,FOLLOW robots meta tag, otherwise (e.g. start=16&items=15) put NOINDEX.
I don’t know whether this method can help with shops using descriptions pulled from a vendor’s data feed, but I doubt it. If Google can determine and suppress partial dupes within a site, it can do that with text snippets from other sites too. One question remains: how does Google identify the source?
Share/bookmark this: del.icio.us • Google • ma.gnolia • Mixx • Netscape • reddit • Sphinn • Squidoo • StumbleUpon • Yahoo MyWeb
Subscribe to Entries Comments All Comments