If your name is John Doe and you don’t blog this rant is not for you, because you don’t suffer from truncated form field values. Otherwise check here whether you annoy comment authors on your blog or not. “Annoy” is the polite version by the way, I’m pissed on 99% of the blogs I read. It took me years to write about this issue eventually. Today I had enough.
Look at this form designed especially for John Doe (email@example.com) at http://doe.com/, then duplicated onto all blogs out there, and imagine you’re me going to comment on a great post:
I can’t view what I’ve typed in, and even my browser’s suggested values are truncated because the input field is way too narrow. Sometimes I leave post-URLs with a comment, so when I type in the first characters of my URL, I get a long list of shortened entries from which I can’t select anything. When I’m in a bad mood I swear and surf on without commenting.
I’ve looked at a fair amount of WordPress templates recently, and I admit that crappy comment forms are a minor issue with regard to the amount of duplicated hogwash most theme designers steal from each other. However, I’m sick of crappy form usability, so I’ve changed my comment form today:
Now the input fields should display the complete input values in most cases. My content column is 500 pixels wide, so
size="42" leaves enough space when a visitor surfs with bigger fonts enlarging the labels. If with very long email addresses or URLs that’s not enough, I’ve added title attributes and onchange triggers which display the new value as tooltip when the visitors navigates to the next input field. Also I’ve maxed out the width of the text area. I hope this 60 seconds hack improves the usability of my comment form.
When do you fire up your editor and FTP client to make your comment form convenient? Even tiny enhancements can make your visitors happier.
Share/bookmark this: del.icio.us • Google • ma.gnolia • Mixx • Netscape • reddit • Sphinn • Squidoo • StumbleUpon • Yahoo MyWeb
Subscribe to Entries Comments All Comments